The Wisdom of Insecurity
“Security is mostly a superstition. It does not exist in nature nor do children as a whole experience it. Avoiding danger is not safer in the long run than outright exposure. Life is either a daring adventure or nothing.”
– Helen Keller
One day Ajahn Chah held up a beautiful Chinese tea cup, “To me this cup is already broken. Because I know its fate, I can enjoy it fully here and now. And when it’s gone, it’s gone.” When we understand the truth of uncertainty and relax, we become free.
The broken cup helps us see beyond our illusion of control. When we commit ourselves to raising a child, building a business, creating a work of art, or righting an injustice, some measure of failure as well as success will be ours. This is a fierce teaching. Margaret is an aid worker whose clinic in Kosovo was burned to the ground, yet she began again. She knows that her work is helping people through success and failure. Emilee, who lost her most promising math student to a gang shooting, was broken hearted. But she doesn’t regret having tutored him and now she is tutoring several others in his honor.
We may lose our best piece of pottery in the firing, the charter school we work so hard to create may fold, our start up business may go under, our children may develop problems beyond our control. If we only focus on the results, we will be devastated. But if we know the cup is broken, we can give our best to the process, create what we can and trust the larger process of life itself. We can plan, we can care for, tend and respond. But we cannot control. Instead we take a breath, and open to what is unfolding, where we are. This is a profound shift, from holding on, to letting go. As Suzuki Roshi says, “When we understand the truth of impermanence and find our composure in it, there we find ourselves in Nirvana.”
When people asked Ajahn Chah questions about enlightenment or what happens at death or whether meditation would heal their illness, or whether Buddhist teachings could be practiced equally by westerners, he would smile and say “It’s uncertain, isn’t it?” Chögyam Trungpa called this uncertainty “groundlessness.” With the wisdom of uncertainty, Ajahn Chah could simply relax. Around him was an enormous sense of ease. He didn’t hold his breath or try to manipulate events. He responded to the situation at hand. When a senior western nun left the Buddhist order to become a born again Christian missionary, and then returned to the monastery to try to convert her old friends, many were upset. “How could she do this?” Condused, they asked Ajahn Chah about her. He responded with a laugh, “Maybe she’s right.” With these words, everyone relaxed. When called for, Ajahn Chah could plan the construction of a great temple or oversee the network of over 100 monasteries started by his monks. When disciplining misbehaving monks, he could be decisive, demanding and stern. But there was a spaciousness around all these actions, as if he could turn to you a moment later and smile – like a wink – and say, “It’s uncertain, isn’t it?” He was living proof of the secret of life described in the Bhagavad Gita, “to act well without attachment to the fruits of your actions.”
The trust expressed by Ajahn Chah comes whenever our consciousness rests in the eternal present. “From where I sit,” he said, “nobody comes and no one goes.” “In the middle way, there is no one who is strong or weak, young or old, no one who is born and no one who dies. This is the unconditioned. The heart is free.” The ancient Zen masters call this enlightenment “the trusting mind.” The Zen texts explain how to do so, “To live in Trusting Mind is to be without anxiety about non-perfection.” The world is ‘imperfect.’ Instead of struggling to perfect the world, we relax, we rest in the uncertainty. Then we can act with compassion and we give our best. Without attachment to the outcome, we bring fearlessness and trust to any circumstances.
When Carl began Buddhist practice, the internet company he worked for was in trouble. His marriage felt stale. And he still suffered the effects of growing up with his father’s long-term depression. He looked to meditation training to help him with his anxiety about the future, the insecurity in his marriage, and how often he felt disconnected from himself.
Since childhood Carl had also had a deeply mystical sense of the world. One of the most important moments in his adult life came in a dream about Katie, his youngest daughter. At age four, Katie was hospitalized for viral meningitis and went into a coma. Carl and his wife spent their days at her bedside. The doctors were cautious about her chances of recovery. After five weeks of no change and endless worrying, Katie came to Carl in a dream and told him, “Don’t worry Daddy, it’s all ok.” The next morning as Carl walked into Katie’s room, she opened her eyes and smiled at him. Now she is a healthy fourteen year old.
Carl had glimpsed the truth that there is a grace beyond all our plans. Learning meditation reawakened this trust in him. With mindfulness his stress lifted and he began to feel his body and his senses open. In one sitting Carl said his body felt like tall, graceful kelp floating beneath the waves. His feelings of being stuck and anxious transformed into moments of interest, curiosity, appreciation. He became less worried, more present. More “juicy” he called it. “Letting go of my fears is like removing an overcoat of self. When thoughts and problems that I can’t solve arise, they don’t stick. I rest like kelp in the ocean, in the trusting mind.” Periodically Carl said he forgets this and his insecurity returns. The worrying mind takes hold. Should he stay in his marriage? Should he continue in an uncertain job? Then he remembers the dream of his daughter and Carl relaxes and trusts the not knowing. “Every marriage and every job is insecure if we are honest,” he said.
Eight years later, Carl is still in his marriage and still working at a now successful internet company. His meditation has taught him a trust that is not separate from the insecurity and paradox of life itself.
This excerpt is taken from the book, ” “The Wise Heart”